Scott Edelman
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Writing
    • Short Fiction
    • Books
    • Comic Books
    • Television
    • Miscellaneous
  • Editing
  • Podcast
  • Contact
  • Videos

©2025 Scott Edelman

Happy birthday, Curt Swan!

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Bill Kresse, birthdays, comics, Curt Swan, DC Comics, Superman    Posted date:  February 19, 2012  |  2 Comments


Yes, I know Curt is no longer with us, but he would have turned 82 the other day, and since he was THE Superman artist of my youth, I figured I should take note. His is the face of Superman I see when I close my eyes, though you’d think, based on my age, that face could have easily belonged to Wayne Boring.

As far as I know, I only met Curt once, back in 1973 at a National Cartoonist Society Ruben Awards banquet held at the Waldorf Astoria. I was just a fanboy then, my job in the Marvel Bullpen still in the future. I was the guest of cartoonist Bill Kresse, whom I’d met thanks to a high school class trip to the New York Daily News.

I wore a old tuxedo which had belonged to a family friend, and as is true for all fanboys back then, I carried a sketch pad tucked under one arm. And to the embarrassment of my host, I interrupted the artists as they tried to eat their rubber chicken, and asked for drawings. (At least I assume my actions had to embarrass Bill. He never said. Who knows? Maybe he found them amusing.)

Here’s what Curt graciously drew for me. (more…)

And the incredible Hulk is meant to sound like … Huh? Are you sure?

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, Hulk, Marvel Comics, Stan Lee    Posted date:  February 18, 2012  |  No comment


As I said in my previous post, I’m confident that there’s simply no way you’ll be able to guess the celebrity voice meant to run through your head once Bruce Banner Hulks out.

OK, this is your last chance to take a crack at it. Got your candidate in mind?

Then click away to read the character description I found stuffed in a file cabinet in the Marvel Bullpen back in the mid-’70s.

Well?

Admit it—you didn’t even come close.

Next up—Spider-Man, accompanied by a supporting cast of characters that’ll explain why I believe all of these pages were written in the ’60s.

Now it’s time to guess which celebrity Doctor Strange is supposed to sound like in your head

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, Doctor Strange, Marvel Comics, Stan Lee    Posted date:  February 15, 2012  |  2 Comments


Over the past week, I’ve shared some superhero descriptions I found hidden between drawers in a filing cabinet back in the ’70s when I worked in the Marvel Bullpen—descriptions some of us who worked there at the time think were written by Stan Lee.

So far, you’ve seen write-ups of the X-Men, Captain America, Thor and the Sub-Mariner, complete with suggestions of what voice you were meant to imagine while reading the adventures of each character.

And today we come to Doctor Strange.

But before perusing the scan below, take a moment and think—who should the sorcerer supreme sound like?

Got a name? OK, then click away!

So? Were you in the ballpark?

Well, even if you were, I’m 100% positive that tomorrow, you’ll be stumped. Because there’s simply no way you’ll be able to successfully guess which celebrity’s voice you were meant to hear running through your head while you sounded out the word balloons of the incredible Hulk. It’s a name that totally surprised me.

Give it a shot if you think you’re up to it, but I promise—you’re going to lose!

So what famous voice did Stan Lee think should come out of the Sub-Mariner’s mouth?

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, Marvel Comics, Stan Lee, Sub-Mariner    Posted date:  February 14, 2012  |  No comment


I’ve already shared a few ancient superhero character descriptions with you that were written decades ago by someone at Marvel Comics—presumably Stan Lee, though until there’s some evidence that’s more than just the opinions of me and a few fellow former Bullpenners, we’ll leave that word “presumably” in there.

So far, you’ve seen the X-Men, Captain America, and Thor. (Who knew that the Thunder God was supposed to sound like Richard Chamberlain AND Richard Burton?)

Yesterday, I asked you to try to guess which famous actor Prince Namor, the Sub-Mariner, was meant to sound like in the word balloons of your mind. Did you come up with one? Give the scan below a read and see if you were right.

So … how far off were you?

Now it’s time to give some thought to whose voice comes out of Doctor Strange’s eldritch mouth. Tune in tomorrow to see how close you come!

Why I just sent $100 to help out Gary Friedrich

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, Gary Friedrich, Ghost Rider, Marvel Comics    Posted date:  February 13, 2012  |  No comment


By now you’ve probably heard the story of how Gary Friedrich recently lost his lawsuit against Marvel Comics over the rights to Ghost Rider, and how he’s now not only required to pay the company $17,000 it claims he earned from selling signed merchandise over the years, but also, he can no longer even state that he’s the character’s creator. Neal Adams, who helped get a degree of justice for Superman’s creators, has said that, “Gary is sick, and he’s about to lose his house, and though he will tell you he is not destitute, he needs help.”

Steve Niles has set up a fund to help Gary, and I’d been meaning to send a few bucks his way, because it’s the right thing to do, regardless of what you think about the merits of his lawsuit, but I’ve been busy and/or dithering since Steve got the ball rolling Friday. A few minutes ago, though, I finally got off my butt and sent $100 Gary’s way.

What riled me up enough just now to make me click that donate button? A glimpse at the Bullpen Bulletins page which appeared in all August 1972 Marvel titles announcing the coming of Ghost Rider.

What does it have to say about “a far-out new feature which we think you’re gonna dig”? Several things, but most important, it describes Gary Friedrich as the guy “who dreamed the whole thing up.”

Let me repeat that.

In 1972, Marvel Comics described Gary Friedrich, who’s now legally prevented from calling himself the creator of Ghost Rider, as the person “who dreamed the whole thing up.”

You can see for yourself below. (more…)

Close your eyes. Think of Thor. Which famous actor’s voice do you hear?

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, Marvel Comics, Stan Lee, Thor    Posted date:  February 13, 2012  |  No comment


I’ve already shared with you who Stan Lee thought the X-Men and Captain America were supposed to sound like—at least in character guides he apparently wrote back in the ’60s. (A date based not at all on hard evidence but instead entirely on when and where in the Bullpen I discovered these, internal clues in the characters’ arcs, and some opinions of old Marvel pals.)

And now we come to the bifurcated Thunder God, with one voice as Don Blake, and another as the mighty Thor.

But before you click below, stop and think for a moment. Which actor’s voice do you imagine coming from each personality?

Done pondering?

OK, check it out and see if you were right.

So how close did you come?

Tune in tomorrow to find out whose dulcet tones should echo in your mind when you read the Sub-Mariner’s word balloons!

Apparently, you can B.S. a B.S.-er

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  P. T. Barnum, St. Petersburg Museum of Fine Arts    Posted date:  February 13, 2012  |  No comment


A week or so ago, I downloaded a free Kindle edition of P. T Barnum’s 1880 book The Art of Money Getting or, Golden Rules for Making Money. (And you can, too.) I started reading it on our flight down to Florida last weekend, enjoying it immensely, and then, while visiting the St. Petersburg Museum of Fine Arts, in the midst of its exhibit on Sitter and Subject in Nineteenth-Century Photography, I came face to face with Barnum himself.

I was startled by the double dose of Barnum, and yet, serendipity has always been an active force in my life. So why not yet again?

Barnum’s advice book was published in 1880, so the photo below was of a much younger man, taken in 1855, and not yet looking like the huckster with which we’re familiar.

To convince you the book is worth your time, here’s one of my favorite passages, as you’ll see what happens when Barnum meets a man who puts his own selling skills to shame:

After securing the right vocation, you must be careful to select the proper location. You may have been cut out for a hotel keeper, and they say it requires a genius to “know how to keep a hotel.” You might conduct a hotel like clock-work, and provide satisfactorily for five hundred guests every day; yet, if you should locate your house in a small village where there is no railroad communication or public travel, the location would be your ruin. It is equally important that you do not commence business where there are already enough to meet all demands in the same occupation. I remember a case which illustrates this subject.

When I was in London in 1858, I was passing down Holborn with an English friend and came to the “penny shows.” They had immense cartoons outside, portraying the wonderful curiosities to be seen “all for a penny.” Being a little in the “show line” myself, I said “let us go in here.” We soon found ourselves in the presence of the illustrious showman, and he proved to be the sharpest man in that line I had ever met. He told us some extraordinary stories in reference to his bearded ladies, his Albinos, and his Armadillos, which we could hardly believe, but thought it “better to believe it than look after the proof’.” He finally begged to call our attention to some wax statuary, and showed us a lot of the dirtiest and filthiest wax figures imaginable. They looked as if they had not seen water since the Deluge. (more…)

So which actor was supposed to come to mind when you heard the voice of Captain America?

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Captain America, comics, Marvel Comics, Stan Lee    Posted date:  February 12, 2012  |  1 Comment


As you learned yesterday, someone—I always assumed Stan Lee, and Roy Thomas has since agreed with me on that assumption—felt that Professor X should sound like Leslie Howard … without an English accent.

But how about Captain America? What was he supposed to sound like?

Would you believe … Rock Hudson?

From discussions with others who worked with me in the Bullpen (and some who worked there long before I arrived), I’m leaning away from these having anything to do with educating the writers who’d come after Stan or arming the merchandising department with the ammunition it would need to better sell the characters, and toward them having been written to pitch the characters for cartoons, maybe even the 1966 Marvel Super Heroes series.

I could be wrong … but that’s what my gut’s saying for now.

Check back tomorrow to find out which two actors are supposed to come to mind when you hear the voices of Don Blake and Thor!

Did Stan Lee think Cyclops should sound like Anthony Perkins?

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, Marvel Comics, Stan Lee, X-Men    Posted date:  February 11, 2012  |  2 Comments


Those who’ve visited me at home know I’ve evolved into the opposite of a hoarder. I’m doing my best to live a stripped-down life. But I’ve made an exception for all the paperwork I collected at Marvel Comics in the ’70s, because I think it doesn’t really belong to me; it belong to you. And while digging through a file folder in search of something I’ve yet to find, I instead found something, well, marvelous.

Sometime during my years in the Bullpen I discovered a dozen or so carbon copies of descriptions of Marvel’s central superheroes buried in the back of a file cabinet, barely visible because the sheets had slipped between the drawers. And you know me—I made sure to keep my own copies, of course.

Because the pages only referenced the earliest of Marvel’s characters—the X-Men, the Fantastic Four, Spider-Man, etc.—and because all of the references as to which famous actors’ voices we should imagine coming out of their mouths were of a previous generation, I always assumed these were written by Stan Lee. The only other person I could possibly imagine having been responsible for these based on when they were discovered is Roy Thomas, but I’m pretty sure that if he had created these, he’d have come up with a more contemporary set of actors.

There’s also the fact that (though I’m no typography expert) these seem to have been written using the same typewriter on which Stan composed his Soapboxes for the Bullpen Bulletins pages. (more…)

Want to own a page of original 1972 Teen Titans art?

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, DC Comics, Teen Titans    Posted date:  February 10, 2012  |  No comment


I already told you about my wife’s current auctions, which are still ongoing. But my sister-in-law is also selling something amazing, so please forgive me for shilling for a relative yet again.

The page is from the story “Slaves of the Emperor Bug,” published in the penultimate issue of the first run of Teen Titans, issue #42 (Nov/-Dec. 1972), with art by Art Saaf and Nick Cardy.

Take a look.

You only have from now until Feb 24 to bid, so if you’re interested, check out the auction here.

So ends the commercial message. We now return you to our previously scheduled programing.

‹ Newest 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 Oldest ›
  • Follow Scott


  • Recent Tweets

    • Waiting for Twitter... Once Twitter is ready they will display my Tweets again.
  • Latest Photos


  • Search

  • Tags

    anniversary Balticon birthdays Bryan Voltaggio Capclave comics Cons context-free comic book panel conventions DC Comics dreams Eating the Fantastic food garden horror Irene Vartanoff Len Wein Man v. Food Marie Severin Marvel Comics My Father my writing Nebula Awards Next restaurant obituaries old magazines Paris Review Readercon rejection slips San Diego Comic-Con Scarecrow science fiction Science Fiction Age Sharon Moody Stan Lee Stoker Awards StokerCon Superman ukulele Video Why Not Say What Happened Worldcon World Fantasy Convention World Horror Convention zombies