Scott Edelman
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Writing
    • Short Fiction
    • Books
    • Comic Books
    • Television
    • Miscellaneous
  • Editing
  • Podcast
  • Contact
  • Videos

©2025 Scott Edelman

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 23: Why Howard the Duck Was the Silver Surfer of the ’70s

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Steve Gerber, Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  May 31, 2025  |  No comment


Join me and Neil Ottenstein for a rambling panel about Howard the Duck in which I share the Marvel Comics chaos which caused me to be hired there in 1974, my regrets over having written an issue of Omega the Unknown, my ethical queasiness about owning original art, what it means when I say I knew Stan Lee before he had hair, my terrifying Bullpen encounters with “Jumbo” John Verpoorten, why Howard the Duck was the Silver Surfer of the ’70s, my Times Square street theater with Steve Gerber, the time Howard the Duck had to be hatched instead of laid, how immaturity cost me Captain Marvel, the only time I ever saw Stan Lee get flustered, and more.

You can eavesdrop on all those memories via the embed below or download them at the site of your choice.

Here are several images relating to some of the topics I touched on during the episode —

The Omega the Unknown panels I regret writing

How the Comics Code Authority censored my Omega the Unknown panel
with more info here

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 22: The Conundrum of Condensing Marie Severin into 1,200 Words

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  April 6, 2025  |  No comment


This time around, I grow anxious over a dream discovery of long-lost original comic book artwork, realize I was wrong about a certain Alan Moore/Frank Miller memory, contemplate the difficulty of condensing the life of Marie Severin into a mere 1,200 words, share the meager remains of what was once a massive comic book collection, remember there’s an issue of Fantastic Four I need to track down to solve an early fannish mystery, rededicate myself to Marie Kondo-ing my creative life, and more.

You can eavesdrop on all those memories via the embed below or download them at the site of your choice.

Here are several images to enrich your listening experience —

My recent Tales from the Darkside residuals

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 21: My Long Weekend Annoying MAD Magazine Publisher Bill Gaines

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  March 4, 2025  |  No comment


My latest look back at what I was doing in comics during the ’70s has me remembering the weekend I couldn’t stop myself from teasing Bill Gaines about the National Lampoon‘s satirical slam of MAD magazine, why famed con-runner Phil Seuling castigated us fans one afternoon for mistreating our mothers, the words Gerry Conway wrote for Daredevil’s girlfriend Karen Page in the basement of a Times Square Nathan’s, how my 1980 DC Comics vampire story ended up as a 1987 episode of Tales from the Darkside, the continuing mystery of the martial arts series I’d forgotten I’d tried to write for Deadly Hands of Kung Fu (and what Tony Stark had to do with it), and much more.

You can eavesdrop on all those memories via the embed below or download them at the site of your choice.

Here are several images which should enrich your listening experience —

My Bill Gaines autograph from the 1972 Fan-Addict Convention

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 20: The Barry Smith Comic Book Which Caused Me to Disobey My Parents

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Bob Budiansky, Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  February 25, 2025  |  No comment


In my latest look back at the comics field of the ’70s, I share about the home away from home Phil Seuling built for fandom which earned his recent much-deserved accolade, whether the Ethics columns I wrote for The Comics Journal during the ’80s burned any bridges (and if I even cared those bridges were on fire), the kung fu comic book series I’d completely forgotten I’d pitched to Marvel, why my job in the Bullpen stunned writer/editor/artist Bob Budiansky, the Barry Smith Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. comic which caused me to disobey my parents, my initial fears I might not last long enough at Marvel to be eligible to receive unemployment benefits if I were fired, and much more.

You can eavesdrop on all those memories via the embed below or download them at the site of your choice.

Here are several images to illuminate your listening experience — though you likely won’t understand why without listening —

Phil Seuling and Me in 1971

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 19: What Gerry Conway Wasn’t Allowed to Say About Gwen Stacy in F.O.O.M.

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Gerry Conway, Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  February 19, 2025  |  No comment


While shredding another old notebook from my early comics career, I reminisce about the many wretched one-act plays I created while being taught by famed playwright Jack Gelber, the lie I told Marv Wolfman and Len Wein which got me hired at Marvel, the most wrongheaded conclusion Fredric Wertham reached in Seduction of the Innocent, my plot for an Inhumans strip starring Karnak which had no reason to exist, the most ridiculous method any writer ever conceived of for killing a vampire, what Gerry Conway said about Gwen Stacy which was censored out of his F.O.O.M. interview, the first words to reach readers about my Scarecrow character, and much more.

You can eavesdrop on all those memories via the embed below or download them at the site of your choice.

Here are some images which will shed light on some of what I talk about this episode — but probably won’t make much sense without listening —

Me the Year Before Marvel

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 18: The Day I Should Have Defended Herb Trimpe

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  February 10, 2025  |  2 Comments


Another look back on my early comics career has me considering the possible reason Robert De Niro’s Max Cady character cared about Captain Marvel in the 1991 movie Cape Fear, the day Jim Shooter and I parachuted out of an airplane (and why an ambulance was called), my surprise over a 1974 House of Mystery submission to editor Joe Orlando, why 2025 Scott is curious about what Crystal leaving the Fantastic Four meant to the 1970 fanboy I was, the reason Doc Savage and Scooter Pies are inextricably linked in my memory, my regret over not having defended artist Herb Trimpe from his detractors, and much more.

You can eavesdrop on all those memories via the embed below or download them at the site of your choice.

Here are some images which illustrate some of what I talk about this episode —

Captain Marvel and Black Bolt in Cape Fear

A record of my two parachute jumps

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 17: How My Meeting Margaret Hamilton Became a Marvel Comics Contest

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Bill Kresse, Dave Cockrum, Harlan Ellison, Len Wein, Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  February 3, 2025  |  No comment


Listen in as I look back half a century on what it was like being in the room with Len Wein and Dave Cockrum (or as much as I’m willing to admit) as they plotted Giant-Size X-Men #1, why my mid-’70s likeness still hangs on the wall at Marvel Comics HQ, my freelance income during the first six months of my life as a comics professional, the collaborative short stories my friends and I stayed awake 24 hours to write on Harlan Ellison’s 39th birthday, an article I commissioned for F.O.O.M. about collecting comics in 1975 which should make you weep 50 years later, how my meeting with Wicked Witch of the West Margaret Hamilton ended up being a Marvel Comics caption contest, and much more.

You can eavesdrop on all those memories via the embed below or download them at the site of your choice.

Here are some images which will enrich your listening experience, though they probably won’t make much sense without it —

My caricature on the wall at Marvel HQ

Marie Severin’s cover to F.O.O.M. #16
with her caricature of me circled

Call It Fate #1
with the first short story I ever wrote on the cover

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 16: What Teen Me Got Wrong (Twice!) About Jim Steranko

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Rutland, Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  January 27, 2025  |  No comment


Join me as I look back at the trouble I had getting out of an elevator at the first Star Trek convention, what my ballot looked like when I voted for the 1968 Alley Awards, the composers who wrote the music to match the lyrics I had Rick Jones sing in Captain Marvel #50, what teen me got wrong (twice!) about Jim Steranko, the three comics characters I almost cosplayed as at the 1972 Rutland Halloween parade, the mystery woman who would have been my Beautiful Dreamer on a Forever People float, and much more.

You can eavesdrop on those memories via the embed below or download at the site of your choice.

Here are some images to accompany the listening experience —

The cover to my 1969 Poetry Journal

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 15: My Mysterious Mid-’70s Comic Con Meeting with Anthony Bourdain

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  January 19, 2025  |  No comment


Shredding hundreds of pages torn from notebooks filled by my teen and twentysomething self causes me to reminisce about my collaboration with artist P. Craig Russell which could have been, the poem 18-year-old me wrote about Action Comics #1, my mysterious mid-’70s New Jersey comic convention meeting with Anthony Bourdain, why when it comes to the process of writing I’m a voyeur but not an exhibitionist, the complete lyrics to a song I had Rick Jones sing way back in Captain Marvel #50, my joy upon seeing Superman co-creator Joe Shuster’s name in my old address book, how the Grim Reaper might have prevented my Scarecrow from being born, and much more.

You can eavesdrop on those memories via the embed below or download at the site of your choice.

Here are some images which will enrich your listening experience, though they probably won’t make much sense without it —

Rick Jones sings my song in Captain Marvel #50 (May 1977)

Complete lyrics for “Champagne People”
written December 12, 1973

(more…)

Why Not Say What Happened? Episode 14: Tony Isabella’s Essential Edit of My Early Avengers Script Assist

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Scarecrow, Tony Isabella, Why Not Say What Happened    Posted date:  January 10, 2025  |  No comment


While destroying hundreds of pages of bad poetry I scribbled as a teenager, I made a few surprising discoveries which cause me to reminisce about my poem “Ode on Comic Book Company Loyalty,” written 18 days after I was hired by Marvel Comics, my extremely rough sketch for the second Scarecrow splash page, my team-up with Quicksilver and 7-Eleven to freeze your brain with Slurpees during the summer of 1975, Tony Isabella’s heavy edit on my early Avengers script assist (and why we should all be grateful), my forgotten horror pitches bounced by Marvel in 1974, and much more.

You can eavesdrop on those memories via the embed below or download at the site of your choice.

Here are some images which will enhance your listening experience, and probably won’t make much sense without it —

My 1975 Park Slope Apartment

My Scarecrow Splash Page Sketch

(more…)

1 2 3 Oldest ›
  • Follow Scott


  • Recent Tweets

    • Waiting for Twitter... Once Twitter is ready they will display my Tweets again.
  • Latest Photos


  • Search

  • Tags

    anniversary Balticon birthdays Bryan Voltaggio Capclave comics Cons context-free comic book panel conventions DC Comics dreams Eating the Fantastic food garden horror Irene Vartanoff Len Wein Man v. Food Marie Severin Marvel Comics My Father my writing Nebula Awards Next restaurant obituaries old magazines Paris Review Readercon rejection slips San Diego Comic-Con Scarecrow science fiction Science Fiction Age Sharon Moody Stan Lee Stoker Awards StokerCon Superman ukulele Video Why Not Say What Happened Worldcon World Fantasy Convention World Horror Convention zombies