Scott Edelman
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Writing
    • Short Fiction
    • Books
    • Comic Books
    • Television
    • Miscellaneous
  • Editing
  • Podcast
  • Contact
  • Videos

©2026 Scott Edelman

The things that we carry

Posted by: Scott    Tags:      Posted date:  November 28, 2007  |  No comment


Tim O’Brien was recently referenced in the New York Times Book Review with the following moving quote from his novel The Things They Carried:

A true war story is never moral. It does not instruct, nor encourage virtue, nor suggest proper models of human behavior, nor restrain men from doing the things men have always done. If a story seems moral, do not believe it. If at the end of a war story you feel uplifted, or if you feel that some small bit of rectitude has been salvaged from the larger waste, then you have been made the victim of a very old and terrible lie.

Three things came to mind when I read this:

First, that The Things They Carried is one of those books I know I should have read a long time ago, and always felt bad that I hadn’t. It makes me think that I should put together a list of my top ten “always meant to get to but somehow never found the time” novels and start finding that time.

Second, that a part of me was simultaneously glad I hadn’t yet read it, because otherwise I would have had that memorable passage in mind as I wrote the following section from the story of mine I referred to in an earlier entry: (more…)

Ghosts of conventions past

Posted by: Scott    Tags:      Posted date:  November 27, 2007  |  2 Comments


I’ve been going to conventions since I was fifteen. I started with Phil Seuling’s July 4th comic-book cons, but quickly moved on to science-fiction ones as well. I lived in Brooklyn back then, which meant that I had plenty of Manhattan cons to choose from, and as soon as I discovered them, I went to as many as I could.

During those first few years, I’d go to as many panels as possible, and always sit in the front row, hoping to learn the secrets of the universe. As soon as the panels would end, I’d pop up to get autographs of each participant in a sketchbook I always carried. (Yes, that’s right. I was one of those.) Last night, while searching for something completely different, I came across the sheet below, which I believe was from the 1972 LunaCon. It immediately brought me back to those early days I spent wandering the Statler Hilton Hotel, when gods still walked the Earth.

The first column includes autographs from Lester Del Rey, Arthur C. Clarke, John Jakes, Baird Searles, and Gordon R. Dickson … but then there’s a final name I can’t identify. The first name seems to begin with an “F” (Fred? Frank?), but it might also be a “J,” and the last name starts with a “W”, with (maybe) a crossed “t” at the end. I looked through the Ws in various SF encyclopedias, and couldn’t find a name that appeared to match the scrawl. Anyone have an idea who that could be?

The second column starts with someone named Marilyn Chris, but I can’t remember who that was, or why I got her autograph. The only Marilyn Chris I can uncover is a soap-opera star—but why would she have been at a LunaCon? She doesn’t seem to have starred in anything science-fictional. Is there another Marylyn Chris out there? After that is another mystery name, what looks like Robert S. Kalb or Kalf—but who is that? Again, Googling hasn’t helped. Then come the familiar names—Richard E. Peck, L. Sprague de Camp, Charles Manson, George Alec Effinger, Marion Zimmer Bradley, Hans Stefan Santesson, and Frank Belknap Long.

And no, Charles Manson wasn’t really at a science-fiction convention. That’s the signature of Merry Prankster Paul Krassner, infamous for (among other things) having published Wally Wood’s Disneyland Memorial Orgy centerspread, back when he was the editor of The Realist.

Any idea who those three mystery panelists were? Does anyone have an old program book which could clear things up?

A few questions (but few answers) about genre

Posted by: Scott    Tags:      Posted date:  November 25, 2007  |  No comment


I’m behind on reading Publishers Weekly, so I’ve only just caught up with the November 5 issue, which includes the magazine’s choices for the 150 Best Books of the Year. The categories used are Fiction, Poetry, Mystery, SF/Fantasy/Horror (all rolled into one), Romance, Comics, NonFiction, Religion, Religious Fiction, Lifestyle, Children’s Picture Books, Children’s Fiction, Children’s NonFiction, and Children’s Comics. There were aspects of the list I found puzzling, but then, I always get confused when walls are built between genres.

Which brings me to a few questions:

If Ellen Datlow‘s state-of-the-art horror anthology Inferno is included in the SF/Fantasy/Horror category, why is Joe Hill’s Heart-Shaped Box, indisputably a horrific ghost story, counted as Fiction?

What’s the reason that In War Times, Kathleen Ann Goonan’s WWII alternate history story, is considered SF/Fantasy/Horror, when Jamestown, Matthew Sharpe’s post-apocalyptic re-imagining of the Jamestown settlement, is considered Fiction?

Why is Kay Kenyon’s Bright of the Sky, about an accident that sends a family into an alternate reality, counted as SF/Fantasy/Horror, but Liz Maverick’s Wired, a cyberpunk story of a computer programmer hunted by strange men who can alter reality, painted a Romance?

Was J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows listed as Children’s Fiction rather than simply Fiction because you’re unlikely to ever see an adult reading it? (more…)

Editing the future

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  magazines    Posted date:  November 24, 2007  |  No comment


I just received advance copies of the February 2008 issue of SCI FI magazine, which won’t be officially on sale until December 10. Zachary Quinto’s face isn’t on the cover due to a Heroes article—he’s there because we decided to make our cover feature this time around a sneak peek at the upcoming Star Trek film. It’s by far the longest lead sneak peek we’ve ever done, since the film is still more than a year away.

February2008SCIFIMagazine

Also covered in the issue are the movies Cloverfield, The Water Horse, One Missed Call, Fanboys, The Eye, Alien vs. Predator: Requiem, The Spiderwick Chronicles, and Jumper, plus the new TV series Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles and Ghost Hunters International. (more…)

That sinking feeling

Posted by: Scott    Tags:      Posted date:  November 23, 2007  |  No comment


The news this morning brings word of a cruise ship sinking in Antarctic waters, and since Irene and I know what it feels like to be aboard a cruise ship in Antarctic waters, the thought of passengers hearing midnight cries of “Abandon ship!” for real instead of as a drill strikes a little too close.

According to the story in the New York Times:

BUENOS AIRES, Argentina (AP) — More than 150 passengers and crew took to lifeboats in Antarctic waters on Friday after their cruise ship hit an object and began taking on water through a hole in the hull, Britain’s coast guard said. No injuries were reported.

I’m glad to see that Lindblad’s M.S. Endeavor, which was our home away from home back in January 2005, was involved in the rescue mission rather than being the ship that required evacuation. (more…)

Who was that masked man?

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  my writing    Posted date:  November 22, 2007  |  No comment


Earlier this year, I published a story in Zencore!—only no one except for me and the editor/publisher knows yet exactly which story that was. Des Lewis wanted readers to encounter the stories inside with no preconceived ideas based on the reputations of the writers, and so he presented the 17 short stories with no bylines attached. A list of authors appeared on the back cover only, in random order, with no clue as to who wrote what.

NemoSevenCover

An announcement will be made marrying the stories to their authors in just a few weeks, but Jetse de Vries decided not to wait, and took a stab at each story’s authorship. (more…)

Failing Better

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  Paris Review    Posted date:  November 21, 2007  |  No comment


I just finished the Fall 2007 issue of The Paris Review, a magazine I’ve been reading since high school, and which I’ve been receiving ever since 1979 as part of a lifetime subscription my wife bought me that year for our anniversary. (We’ve now been married thirty-one years. Thank you for asking.)

Irene paid $100 at the time, doing so just a month before the publisher raised the price of lifetime subscriptions tenfold to $1,000. Considering that the individual issue cover price is currently $12, I’d say we came out ahead on the deal, even accounting for inflation. So much so, in fact, that George Plimpton wrote me about twenty years into the sub, asking whether I felt embarrassed about having gotten such a good bargain, and suggesting that I make an additional donation to help support the magazine.

We declined. After all, isn’t that what a lifetime subscription is all about, taking a gamble? And most of the time, the house wins. I’m sure if I’d died a year or two into the sub, I wouldn’t have gotten a refund.

I’ve always enjoyed the Paris Review interviews most of all. There are usually at least two per issue, beginning with E. M. Forster back in 1953. The Fall issue includes an interview with novelist David Grossman. I’ll profess my ignorance here by admitting that I’ve never read him before, so the fascinating things he had to say were completely new to me. (more…)

Three stories I will never write

Posted by: Scott    Tags:      Posted date:  November 20, 2007  |  No comment


For a writer, the true question isn’t “Where do you get your ideas?,” but instead, “How do you decide which of the many hundreds of ideas you get is worth pursuing?” If the subconscious is a garden, the issue for me has never been one of fertilizing, but rather of pruning.

For example, when I learned that Jacques Futrelle, the author of the “Thinking Machine” stories I’d loved as a kid (such as the classic “The Problem of Cell 13”), died aboard the Titanic, a story idea immediately came to me. What if Futrelle himself had a detecting adventure onboard similar to those of his creation Prof. Augustus S. F. X. Van Dusen, and died trying to save the doomed ship? Perhaps the only reason there had been any survivors at all was because of something he did, and he sacrificed his life on behalf of those who made it out alive. I’m sure there’s an intriguing story to be built of that, but other ideas attracted me more, so it will be up to someone else to write.

Then there was the time I learned that Charles Dickens, who’d died before completing The Mystery of Edwin Drood, had once offered to tell Queen Victoria how the series was to end, so she wouldn’t have to live in suspense like a commoner. The incident could very well be apocryphal, and besides, she supposedly refused anyway. But what if she hadn’t rejected Dickens’ gift? When if Queen Victoria was the only person in the world who truly knew how the novel was to end, but kept it to herself? After all, that secret would be one of her most valuable possessions. I once thought of writing the last chapter of Drood as told by Queen Victoria, but soon decided that, too, was a tale best left to someone else.

PortableObituary

Well, inspiration just happened again. I was skimming The Portable Obituary, an encyclopedia of celebrity deaths written by Michael Largo, who’d won a Stoker Award for his previous non-fiction book. In it, he shares the fact (which might be widely known, but was new to me) that novelist Albert Camus, author of The Stranger, apparently died in a car crash while carrying in his pocket an unused train ticket to the same destination to which he’d been driving, as if he’d changed his mind at the last minute. I’m sure there’s a story to be mined out of this nugget of information as well, either an existential tale of how Camus had come to change his mind, or an alternate history detailing what that train trip would have been like.

In any event, this recent fact, like those two earlier occurrences, will not be written by me. (Who knows? Perhaps they’ve even already been written by others, and I’m unaware of it.) I have hundreds of other ideas I find far more intriguing. So I offer these to the blogosphere to be fleshed out by anyone who wants them.

My faults are Legion

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  comics, Marvel Comics, Scarecrow    Posted date:  November 19, 2007  |  No comment


It’s a good thing when you look back at old writing and shudder—isn’t it? At least I hope it is, because I’ve been given many opportunities to shudder lately.

More than thirty years ago, back when I was working at Marvel Comics, I created a character called the Scarecrow, who debuted in Dead of Night #11 (August 1975), continued his adventures in Marvel Spotlight #26 (February 1976), and then faded away as the horror explosion imploded, popping up only occasionally thereafter handled by other writers. I haven’t done any work for either Marvel or DC since the early ’80s.

DeadofNight11

Marvel has recently begun packaging some of my old stories as a minor part of its compilation volumes, and the latest of these is the hardcover book Legion of Monsters, which stars Morbius the Living Vampire, Werewolf by Night, Man-Thing and others on the cover, and relegates the Scarecrow only to the two tales inside. This is the fourth reprint volume I’ve been a part of lately, and they bring about mixed emotions. (more…)

First review of my story “Almost the Last Story by Almost the Last Man”

Posted by: Scott    Tags:  my writing, Postscripts    Posted date:  November 18, 2007  |  No comment


My story “Almost the Last Story by Almost the Last Man, just out in PostScripts 12, has been reviewed—as favorably as one could ever hope for—by Val Grimm at The Fixx:

Although it is uneven, this issue is worth buying and keeping for its most promising stories, two of which, “Almost The Last Story By Almost The Last Man” by Scott Edelman and “Ghost Technology From The Sun” by Paul Jessup, show thoughtfulness and literary craft that deserve special recognition and remembrance.

The unnamed narrator (I suspect his name is Walter) of “Almost The Last Story By Almost The Last Man” is a writer doing research who seeks refuge in the rare book vault of a library, which is attacked by zombies. Walled in with his books, he struggles to comprehend what is happening by telling stories, mostly of what he imagines is happening in the world outside the library. His meta-narrative is an exploration of the impulse to write and why telling stories is human. All the vignettes our male Scheherazade formulates to forestall and forget the inevitable involve affection or dedication of one kind or another: bonds between people, or between humans and zombies. Death doesn’t part his husbands and wives in their love or hatred; mothers adore their strange children; priests attend to their flocks; and survivors seek other survivors. The unflinching mayhem of this story is heartrending rather than perverse or disgusting, as life is destroyed and, tattered, continues in unlife. Again and again, our narrator imagines a man on a mountain, who has never heard a whimper of the chaos below, poking in the dirt with a stick and talking to his son, a darkly hopeful image which recalls the torturer’s horse scratching its innocent behind on a tree in W.H. Auden’s “Musée des Beaux Arts.”

That’s the first time I’ve ever been favorably compared to W.H. Auden!

‹ Newest 358 359 360 361 362 363 Oldest ›
  • Follow Scott


  • Recent Tweets

    • Waiting for Twitter... Once Twitter is ready they will display my Tweets again.
  • Latest Photos


  • Search

  • Tags

    anniversary Balticon birthdays Bryan Voltaggio Capclave comics Cons context-free comic book panel conventions DC Comics dreams Eating the Fantastic food garden horror Irene Vartanoff Len Wein Man v. Food Marie Severin Marvel Comics My Father my writing Nebula Awards Next restaurant obituaries old magazines Paris Review Readercon rejection slips San Diego Comic-Con Scarecrow science fiction Science Fiction Age Sharon Moody Stan Lee Stoker Awards StokerCon Superman ukulele Video Why Not Say What Happened Worldcon World Fantasy Convention World Horror Convention zombies